RSS

Raided: Moorley Farm East, Newmarket #DopingInSport

On the back of Horse & Hound’s article published yesterday, http://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/illegal-drugs-seized-at-stansted-airport/ I’ve spent most of the day trying to find out further details regarding this flight. However, I seem to have stumbled across something bigger.

While British trainers have been raiding prizes throughout the racing world in recent weeks, DEFRA sent a raiding party of their own to Moorley Farm East, Newmarket.

Moorley Farm East, Newmarket. 124 veterinary medicinal products were seized because they were not authorised in the UK and had not been imported into the UK in accordance with the Regulations. These medicines, in varying quantities, were to be used on horses and included injectables, anaesthetics, anti —inflammatories and antibiotics.

Defra

http://www.vmd.defra.gov.uk/public/enforcement_notices.aspx#seizure

Moorley Farm East is listed on the Directory Of The Turf as part of the Darley Stud Management Company.

Moorley

http://www.directoryoftheturf.com/profile.cfm/searchid/13360

Newmarket takes centre stage, for all the wrong reasons, again. Let’s see how this one plays out.

 
1 Comment

Posted by on September 9, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

BHA seeking shade from “Sungate”

Following Paul Bittar’s appreance on Channel 4 News last night on the back of Frankie Dettori’s return to the saddle, BHA issued a statement regarding the veterinary product Sungate:

In light of the interview on last night’s Channel 4 News with the British Horseracing Authority’s (BHA) Chief Executive Paul Bittar, in which he was specifically asked to comment on the veterinary product Sungate, the BHA has released the following statement and update.

Sungate is a product developed by an Italian company, produced and licensed for equine use in Italy. Its use in the UK is legal, but only when imported under the Special Import Certificate scheme administered by the Veterinary Medicines Directorate.

The product is intended to assist in the treatment and management of joint disease in horses. Sungate contains stanozolol, an anabolic steroid and consequently a prohibited substance under the Rules of Racing.

The BHA became aware of the use of the product on horses in training following a visit to Gerard Butler’s yard in February 2013 as part of its testing in training sampling programme. Subsequently it became apparent that a veterinary practice, which had legally imported Sungate into the UK, had recommended its initial administration to horses in the care of Gerard Butler.

The BHA has met with representatives of the veterinary practice in question. As a result of that meeting the BHA believes that Gerard Butler was not the only trainer to whom the administration of Sungate was recommended.

Veterinary surgeons are not bound by the Rules of Racing, but are subject to their own rules of professional conduct. Therefore in order to establish the extent of the use of the product, BHA Investigating Officers will be interviewing trainers who are known to use the same veterinary practice.

Under the Rules of Racing, licensed trainers are strictly liable for the administration of any prohibited substances administered to horses under their care and control.

Thankfully the idea of an amnesty which was mooted by the Racing Post due the scandal has been put to bed.

So what about “Sungate”? On the back of the BHA visit to Gerard Butler’s yard, The National Trainers Federation issued a statment to their members on the 7th March 2013 regarding “Sungate”. It read:

The BHA has asked us to let you know that a product called “Sungate” has been brought to their attention. This contains Stanozolol, a prohibited substance under the Rules of Racing and you should therefore avoid using it

The practice linked to Gerard Butler, and possibly embroiled in this scandal, is Rossdale and Partners, Newmarket, Suffolk. Peter Ramzan is a partner at Rossdale’s

“Peter H.L. Ramzan BVSc(Sydney), MRCVS Horses in training, dentistry” http://www.rossdales.com/about-us/, and at the 2012 European Veterinary Conference in Amsterdam, he commented on the “Preliminary clinical impressions on the use of stanozolol as a novel intra-articular therapy for athletic horses: 60 cases”

Here are a couple of extacts:

Abstracts European Veterinary Conference Voorjaarsdagen 2012

Abstracts European Veterinary Conference Voorjaarsdagen 2012

Abstracts European Veterinary Conference Voorjaarsdagen 2012 (2)

Abstracts European Veterinary Conference Voorjaarsdagen 2012 (2)

Good luck finding that shaded area.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on May 17, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

“end of the beginning” says Bittar. Well what about the beginning Paul?

Followers of this blog will realise I have had by doubts about the BHA Integrity Department in its previous form for some time.  We have had BHA Committee Members administering prohibited race day substances to horses under the impression they would pass a doping control test. We’ve seen panel hearing reports showing that Paul Scotney and Tim Morris didn’t think a base test was necessary which would have cleared a trainer of doping within weeks, but that trainer had to wait two years for the case to be resolved, and still then it wasn’t a satisfactory resolution.

Extracts from “Doping and Medical Control: AWOL within British Racing 2000-2009”

 The RCVS even questions the validity of the BHA testing procedures;

“While it is evident from the BHA’s Guidelines that the sensitivity of the tests is in a process of continual development, the Committee is unable to speculate as to why tranexamic acid had not tested positive on horses to which Mr Main had administered it on previous occasions. However, it is satisfied that Mr Main believed at the time he administered the injection that Moonlit Path would not test positive for tranexamic acid.”

Further question marks over the effectiveness of doping control were raised in the recent allegation of milkshaking made against James Boyle. A baseline CO2 test would have enabled accurate conclusions to be drawn but that was deemed “unnecessary” by Paul Scotney, the former Director of Integrity Services, Compliance and Licensing, and Professor Tom Morris, then Director of Equine Science and Welfare.

Both Paul Scotney and Professor Tim Morris have left the British Horse Racing Authority in recent months, during a much needed reconfiguration of the BHA services and structure. Paul Bittar said “We are proud that British Racing is justifiably held in high regard on the subject, but we know there is no room for complacency.”

Extract from “Open Letter to BHA Director of Legal, Integrity and Risk”

4)       Professor Morris said in his written statement that he believed that testing for tranexamic acid had been in place for some time. He also said that he was aware of only one other instance of a horse testing positive in March 2009, which was shortly after Moonlit Path’s positive test.

Obviously the tests upto to February 2009 were either too infrequent, or not upto standard.  Was there any noticeable change in testing procedures between 2003 and February 2009?

8)       The Committee carefully observed Mr Main when he was asked questions about the use of the term “pre-race check” and observed his obvious unease. Any disagreement Mr Main may have had with the BHA’s rules of racing did not justify him perpetuating a practice that he knew was designed to conceal from the BHA that tranexamic acid had been administered to a horse on a race day.

Extract from “Day 335 at the BHA House…”

Paul Scotney will step aside from his full-time role with effect from 14th December 2012, but as part of a transition plan will remain a part of the BHA’s ability to protect the sport from corruption, providing advice on investigations and strategy.

BHA Chief Executive, Paul Bittar, said the decision for Paul Scotney to transition from his current full-time role was agreed mutually and arose during their discussions in reviewing the BHA Integrity operations, future needs and structure.

The British Horseracing Authority (BHA) announced today that Professor Tim Morris, Director of Equine Science and Welfare, is to leave the organisation. His departure forms part of the ongoing restructure of BHA services, led by Chief Executive Paul Bittar.

Paul Bittar, BHA Chief Executive, said:

“Reconfiguring the BHA services and structure is an evolutionary process and further work will be done with Tim in the coming weeks to imbed the new structure for Veterinary Operations combined with our important role in medication control.

Professor Tim Morris and Paul Scotney deemed further testing to establish a baseline TCO2 reading for the gelding as unnecessary. Their titles again; Director of Equine Science and Welfare and Director of Integrity Services, Compliance, and Licensing.

So how did the Mahmood Al Zarooni raids come about. Well Paul Bittar stated it was mix of random testing programme and intelligence.  The question journalists should be asking Bittar is during the period under Paul Scotney’s stewardship, how often was intelligence not acted upon or ignored? Six months after two former heads of departments leave the British Horseracing Authority, the biggest doping scandal to hit British racing is uncovered. That’s a worrying coincidence.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on April 27, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , ,

The MAZ Files Blockbuster: Coming Soon

When reading the statement from Paul Bittar, and accompanying quotes following today’s hearing, it read like the script for a trailer of a Hollywood blockbuster:

The BHA will conduct the testing of the horses with the analytical work being carried out by HFL Sport Science. Godolphin have stated they will cooperate fully with this process. In addition, we will also provide advice to Godolphin of necessary changes to its procedures and controls where appropriate, and this will be supported by Godolphin’s own review.

Wow, a MAZ Files sequel directed by Godolphin seemingly out soon too judged by that quote. Bonus! Wonder if it’s as good as the Disciplinary Panel’s movie where it picks out all the bloopers.

Another titbit on offer too, possibly a star studded supporting cast?

Two more Godolphin employees have also been named by Zarooni as parties to the doping, according to Crisford.

We will be taken to exotic locations:

The steroids, meanwhile, and in considerable quantity, had been imported from Dubai, which is of itself illegal.

We will also be privy to out-takes and watch people distance themselves from the action…wide shot needed for this one:

“I didn’t tell him not to do it,” Crisford said, “because I didn’t think for one minute that he would be doing it.

Tears will be shed:

Crisford added that the unnamed vet’s assistant who injected the steroids into Zarooni’s horses was also one of the victims in the case

Villain, Mahmood Al Zarooni described as:

a reckless person who has shown no respect for racing

I can’t wait for this blockbuster:

The full details of this will be formally addressed in the Disciplinary Panel’s findings, to be published in due course and once they are available.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on April 25, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , ,

Sheikh Mohammed: Biggest hypocrite in British Racing?

It’s late, I’m tired, I’m tweeting about doping…again, I’m bleeding followers, I need Lasix.

Lasix in UK is banned substance, in the US it is not. In one country I’ve broken the rules, in another I’m playing within them. If I had used Lasix in the US, and raced in the UK later date no bother. If I had used Lasix in the UK…big bother.

So what has this got to do with Sheikh Mohammed…everything.

Sheikh Mohammed released a “strongly worded” statement today regarding the Godolphin Doping Scandal:

“I was appalled and angered to learn that one of our stables in Newmarket has violated Godolphin’s ethical standards and the rules of British racing. I have been involved in British horse racing for 30 years and have deep respect for its traditions and rules. I built my country based on the same solid principles. There can be no excuse for any deliberate violation. Godolphin is fully cooperating with the British Horseracing Authority to get to the bottom of this matter and take any appropriate disciplinary action. I have ordered the Godolphin management to undertake an immediate review of our internal procedures and controls to ensure to prevent any reoccurrence of this type of activity in any stables of mine. We will be locking down the Moulton Paddocks stables with immediate effect, and I have instructed that I want a full round of blood samples, and dope testing done on every single horse on that premises. I can assure the racing public that no horse will run from that yard this season until I have been absolutely assured by my team that the entire yard is completely clean. I have worked hard to ensure that Godolphin deserves its reputation for integrity and sportsmanship, and I have reiterated to all Godolphin employees that I will not tolerate this type of behaviour.”

Reminder of Mahmood Al Zarooni’s statement:

Al Zarooni said: “I deeply regret what has happened. I have made a catastrophic error. Because the horses involved were not racing at the time, I did not realise that what I was doing was in breach of the rules of racing.

Again, we go back to the terminology used by MAZ in his statement: “Because the horses involved were not racing at the time, I did not realise that what I was doing was in breach of the rules of racing.

So why the importance of that line. Well we’ve seen in the fallout articles online in Australia stating drugs that MAZ horses have tested positive for are legal in AUS when out of competition. As pointed out by Geoffrey Riddle here http://www.thenational.ae/sport/horse-racing/anabolic-steroids-permitted-in-uae-to-aid-horses-recovery-from-colic-or-serious-fractures#ixzz2RQI1xjyW

“In Australia, the rules of racing are exactly the same as they are in the UAE”

In short, if Mahmood Al Zarooni had carried out his doping programme in Dubai, shipped them back into the UK, he would not have been in breach of any rules, Joe Public would be none the wiser and Sheikh Mohammed would not need to bring ethics to the table.

So, maybe before Sheikh Mohammed starts slagging off one of his appointed trainers, he should get his own house, well Emirates Racing Authority, in order first and then his appointed trainers would know where they stand.

 
2 Comments

Posted by on April 25, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , ,

“because the horses involved were not racing at the time…”

That’s a line from Mahmoud al-Zarooni’s statement on Goldolphin.com today following the news that 11 horses in his care have tested positive for anabolic steriods.

His comments in full below:

Al Zarooni said: “I deeply regret what has happened. I have made a catastrophic error. Because the horses involved were not racing at the time, I did not realise that what I was doing was in breach of the rules of racing. I can only apologise for the damage this will cause to Godolphin and to racing generally.”

Now elsewhere on the site is Mahmood Al-Zarooni bio http://www.godolphin.com/about-us/people/mahmood-al-zarooni/

His big break came in 2008/2009 “when H.H. Sheikh Mohammed took him to assist Mubarak bin Shafya at Al Asifa Stables.

He sampled a taste of major triumph when Mubarak bin Shafya saddled a remarkable double at the 2009 Dubai World Cup meeting gaining success with the front-running Gladiatorus in the Group One US$5-million Dubai Duty Free and then with Eastern Anthem who secured a pulsating last-gasp triumph in the Group One US$5-million Dubai Sheema Classic.

Following those victories, H.H. Sheikh Mohammed asked Mahmood Al Zarooni to join the Godolphin team as one of Saeed bin Suroor’s assistants.

He gained valuable knowledge during his first season in Newmarket when the stable posted 148 winners in Britain, enjoyed Classic success thanks to Mastery’s Ladbrokes St Leger victory and captured a Breeders’ Cup race with Vale Of York.

After a further winter with Saeed bin Suroor in Dubai, he was ready to step up and become a Godolphin trainer ahead of the 2010 campaign in Europe and beyond, operating out of his home base at Godolphin Marmoom stables in Dubai, whilst spending his summer at Moulton Paddocks in Newmarket.”

As far as I am aware, this is the first winter where horses that have not raced at the Dubai Carnival stayed in Newmarket as per an email confirmation I received from Godolphin. Mahmood Al-Zarooni bleeds Godolphin, so for him to utter the line “because the horses involved were not racing at the time, I did not realise that what I was doing was in breach of the rules of racing.” leaves you wondering how the Godolphin operation works as a whole.

As for Al-Zarooni’s Big Race Wins:

Shadwell Fillies´ Mile (Group 1) 28Sep12 Certify £92,721
Ladbrokes St Leger Stakes (Group 1) 15Sep12 Encke £311,905
Dubai World Cup (Group 1) 31Mar12 Monterosso £3,870,968
Dubai Gold Cup (Group 3) 31Mar12 Opinion Poll £387,097
Al Maktoum Challenge R3 (Group 1) 10Mar12 Capponi £154,839
Shadwell Fillies´ Mile (Group 1) 23Sep11 Lyric Of Light £92,721
Darley Yorkshire Oaks (Group 1) 18Aug11 Blue Bunting £175,801
Darley Irish Oaks (Group 1) 17Jul11 Blue Bunting £212,500
Prince of Wales´s Stakes (Group 1) 15Jun11 Rewilding £227,080
Qipco 1000 Guineas (Group 1) 1May11 Blue Bunting £213,739
Dubai Sheema Classic (Group 1) 26Mar11 Rewilding £1,923,077
Premio Gran Criterium (Group 1) 9Oct10 Biondetti £119,469
Deutsches Derby (Group 1) 18Jul10 Buzzword £265,487
Godolphin Mile (Group 2) 27Mar10 Calming Influence £370,370

I don’t think I need to list other big race winners for the boys in blue, I think you get the picture.

“Wintered well in Dubai.” How many times have we heard that line? 503,000 results as per Google.

 
3 Comments

Posted by on April 22, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

17 days and counting – A response…of sorts

On the 14th February 2013, an open letter was emailed to the BHA FAO Adam Brickell, BHA Director of Integrity, Legal and Risk. Still we wait for a response from Adam Brickell, but I did get a reply from Robin Mounsey, Communications and Online Manager, when chasing them up for a response:

Hello Dan,I am unaware as to whether Adam intends to respond or not.

However, I would point out that your letter is over 1,200 words long and divided into ten incredibly detailed questions about a case of nearly four years ago and related to findings published two years ago. It also includes several sarcastic comments along the lines of “Ouch – That’s got to hurt?” If I was a member of public writing to a senior Director of an organisation I would probably not expect a response to such a letter.

That is just my view though.

Regards,
Robin

So let me ask just the following:

Due to the actions of a BHA Committee Member, were the BHA complicit in the administeration of illegal race day substances during the period of 2003-2009? In turn evidence at a Disciplinary Hearing was suppressed to ensure the scale of systematic doping within the sport was never known until RCVS findings were published two years later in the hope that questions such as the ones in my original letter were never asked?

 
1 Comment

Posted by on March 3, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Doping and Medical Control within British Horseracing – AWOL 2003-2009?

In June 2009 headline in the Daily Telegraph read as follows:

Nicky Henderson has been fined a record £40,000 and banned from making entries for three months after being found guilty of administering an anti-bleeding drug to the Queen’s horse Moonlit Path at Huntingdon in February.

BHA’s Full Decisions and Reasons can be found here, but initially I want to focus on one section in particular:

Evidence at this Enquiry

12. The main factual evidence came just from Henderson. He had given notice that he intended to call Mr Main, and he also produced a statement signed on 3 June 2009 from him. This statement was also sent direct by Mr Main to the BHA on 3 June, under cover of a letter in which he expressed disagreement with the note compiled by the BHA investigators of his interview on 9 April. (Mr Main had refused to allow this to be recorded at the time). But on 18 June 2009, the BHA was informed by Henderson’s representatives that Mr Main would not be called to give evidence, because he was refusing to come.

13. As will be apparent from the analysis of this case below, it is obvious that Mr Main had some important, perhaps vital evidence to give. The Panel therefore raised with the parties the possibility of adjourning the enquiry to see if Mr Main might respond to invitations to attend from the BHA or even from the Panel direct. Mr Norris QC for Henderson forcefully opposed this course, and Mr McPherson QC for the BHA doubted whether Mr Main might respond to their invitation, because of the earlier dispute with him about the accuracy of the 9 April interview note.

14. The Panel saw an additional possible benefit from an adjournment. This would have allowed evidence to be taken from Tom Symonds, who was also, in the Panel’s view, someone with an important story to tell. But Mr Norris QC’s reaction to that was again to resist any adjournment, because he did not propose to call any evidence from Symonds. The Panel’s eventual decision was not to adjourn, because it was uncertain whether Mr Main would agree to give evidence, even with the “encouragement” he might be given by drawing his attention to Rule 6 of the Rules of Racing. It remained the Panel’s view that Mr Main and Mr Symonds had potentially crucial evidence to give.

So what was this evidence? Well we had to wait for the findings of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeon to be published on the 22nd February 2011. Full report can be found here

An extract below from the findings of Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons:

“The Committee has considered very carefully the explanation put forward by Mr Main for the use of the term “pre-race check” on Moonlit Path’s clinical records, and indeed, on the invoice. It has concluded that the use of the term was, in effect, a protocol developed over several years between the practice and Mr Henderson to conceal the administration of tranexamic acid by injection to a horse on a race day.”

So who was James Main? Well he worked within the practice of O’Gorman Slater Main & Partners which has upwards of 25 yards in and around Lambourn on its books. He was member of the following BHA Committees: Counter-Analysis Advisory Committee and Veterinary Committee as well as being a NTF Veterinary Advisor.  Taking this into consideration, this further extract from RCVS findings makes for interesting reading:

“At the outset of the hearing, Mr Main admitted the first head of charge (a) (i) namely that on 19th February 2009, he injected Moonlit Path, which he knew to be racing later that day, with tranexamic acid when he knew that to do so would result in a breach of Instruction C9 and Rule 221B (i) of the BHA rules of racing. He accepted that at the relevant time he was aware of the provisions of Instruction C9 which prohibited any substance being given to a horse at any time on the day of a race whether by an injection, orally or any other method with the exception of normal feed and water by mouth.”

The RCVS concluded the following:

“It has concluded that Mr Main did not know at the time he administered the injection that, if tested, Moonlit Path would prove positive for tranexamic acid. It accepts Mr Main’s oral evidence that he, and other veterinary surgeons at the practice, had administered tranexamic acid to horses on race days at Mr Henderson’s yard over a significant period of time without positive testing.”

So here we have a member of BHA Counter-Analysis Advisory Committee and Veterinary Committee administering illegal race day substances having the confidence in the Medical Control procedure that it would come back as a negative test.  The RCVS even questions the validity of the BHA testing procedures;

“While it is evident from the BHA’s Guidelines that the sensitivity of the tests is in a process of continual development, the Committee is unable to speculate as to why tranexamic acid had not tested positive on horses to which Mr Main had administered it on previous occasions. However, it is satisfied that Mr Main believed at the time he administered the injection that Moonlit Path would not test positive for tranexamic acid.”

Further question marks over the effectiveness of doping control were raised in the recent allegation of milkshaking made against James Boyle. A baseline CO2 test would have enabled accurate conclusions to be drawn but that was deemed “unnecessary” by Paul Scotney, the former Director of Integrity Services, Compliance and Licensing, and Professor Tom Morris, then Director of Equine Science and Welfare.

Both Paul Scotney and Professor Tim Morris have left the British Horse Racing Authority in recent months, during a much needed reconfiguration of the BHA services and structure. Paul Bittar said “We are proud that British Racing is justifiably held in high regard on the subject, but we know there is no room for complacency.”

However, the findings of the RCVS regarding the administration/testing of tranexamic acid and the lack of a fundamental baseline test in a doping case cast serious doubt as to the rigour of BHA’s Doping and Medical Control between 2003 and 2009, and in turn the performances of the thoroughbred throughout that period.

 
2 Comments

Posted by on February 19, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Open letter to BHA Director of Integrity, Legal and Risk

Dear Mr Adam Brickell,

I have a few questions with regards to the findings published on 22nd February 2011, Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons v James Main and its impact on the Disciplinary Hearing heard in June 2009:

1)       During the hearing the Panel raised the possibility of adjourning the enquiry to see if Mr Main might respond to invitations to attend from the BHA or even from the Panel direct.

Why would the BHA look to suppress such evidence?

2)       Until his resignation following the incident, Mr James Main was the veterinary adviser to the National Trainers Federation (“NTF”) which represents trainers’ interests. As the NTF’s representative he was a member of the British Horseracing Authority’s (“BHA”) Veterinary Committee. He also sat on the BHA’s Counter-Analysis Advisory Committee.

Mr Main therefore knew Instruction C9 regarding the prohibition on any substance other than normal feed and water being given to a horse on the day of a race was introduced in 2003. Obviously it would have been embarrassing for the BHA that a member of the above committees was in front of a disciplinary panel showing his understanding that tranexamic acid was undetectable on testing following a race and that the procedure was widely used by other veterinary surgeons and trainers on race day. Is this why Mr James Main was not called to give evidence?

3)       Professor Morris believed that the laboratory used by the BHA had been able to identify tranexamic acid as part of its testing process for a number of years prior to 2009. However, the only other occasion the BHA had been notified of a positive result showing the presence of tranexamic acid in a sample had been in March 2009.

Again would the evidence of James Main and Tom Symonds have highlighted the inefficiencies of BHA’s Doping Control?

4)       Professor Morris said in his written statement that he believed that testing for tranexamic acid had been in place for some time. He also said that he was aware of only one other instance of a horse testing positive in March 2009, which was shortly after Moonlit Path’s positive test.

Obviously the tests upto to February 2009 were either too infrequent, or not upto standard.  Was there any noticeable change in testing procedures between 2003 and February 2009?

5)       While it is evident from the BHA’s Guidelines that the sensitivity of the tests is in a process of continual development, the Committee is unable to speculate as to why tranexamic acid had not tested positive on horses to which Mr Main had administered it on previous occasions. However, it is satisfied that Mr Main believed at the time he administered the injection that Moonlit Path would not test positive for tranexamic acid.

Ouch – That has got to hurt?

A member of the BHA Counter-Analysis Advisory Committee working on the understanding the horse would not test positive.

6)       The BHA Guidance states “Not all prohibited substances are detectable in racing laboratories but they are still prohibited. Where such substances are of concern to racing authorities they will encourage their racing laboratories to develop new methods to detect them. Do not forget that some samples that have been declared negative are frozen and will be reanalysed if/when new methods are developed”

Has the BHA carried out tests on samples between the period of 2003 and February 2009 to see if they tested positive for tranexamic acid?

7)       The Committee has considered very carefully the explanation put forward by Mr Main for the use of the term “pre-race check” on Moonlit Path’s clinical records, and indeed, on the invoice. It has concluded that the use of the term was, in effect, a protocol developed over several years between the practice and Mr Henderson to conceal the administration of tranexamic acid by injection to a horse on a race day. The Committee is satisfied that Mr Main used the term in the practice clinical record and on the invoice, to conceal that an injection of tranexamic acid had been administered to a horse on a race day. It is sure that the underlying purpose shared by both Mr Main and Mr Henderson was to conceal a breach of Instruction C9 when the BHA inspected the yard’s records. Both Mr Symonds and Mr Pauling showed obvious discomfiture during their evidence when admitting that they knew that no substance should be given to a horse on a race day other than normal food and water and that was why injections of tranexamic acid were not entered into the yard’s own medication record.

How many medical records, at Nicky Henderson’s or other trainers whose vets were O’Gorman Slater Main & Partners, were reviewed following the publication of these findings?

8)       The Committee carefully observed Mr Main when he was asked questions about the use of the term “pre-race check” and observed his obvious unease. Any disagreement Mr Main may have had with the BHA’s rules of racing did not justify him perpetuating a practice that he knew was designed to conceal from the BHA that tranexamic acid had been administered to a horse on a race day.

Ouch – That has got to hurt?

9)       In the witness statement which he provided to the BHA on 3rd June 2009 he said at paragraph 16: “At the time I injected Moonlit Path I was aware that there had been a relatively recent change to the rules of racing in that it had become prohibited to administer any substance on the day of racing. I presumed Mr Henderson was also aware of the rule. I did not ask when she was to run.” Putting to one side that the change in the rule occurred in 2003, the Committee concluded that at the time he prepared his witness statement he was avoiding any admission that he knew Moonlit Path was to race on the same day as he administered the injection when he said “I did not ask when she was to run.”

Can you please advise the time frame Mr James Main was on the BHA’s Counter-Analysis Advisory Committee. Can you please also advise the process re the rule change in 2003 and what committees were involved.

10)   The Committee also concluded that it is inconceivable that an experienced equine veterinary surgeon in Mr Main’s position as the NTF veterinary representative on the BHA Veterinary Committee and a member of the Counter Analysis Committee would not have known of the existence of Instruction C9, or indeed, the other rules of racing referred to in this case. The content of the foreword written by Mr Main on Detection Times Information in the NTF Medication Record is indicative of his state of knowledge when he said “There is an increasing amount of information being published regarding detection times for residues following administration of different medications, this is useful information and the work of the BHA in this area should be applauded. However, trainers should be aware of variations due to individual horse absorption and metabolism differences in drug preparations and routes of administration … Trainers should consult their veterinary surgeon regarding acceptable withdrawal times for a particular medication.”

Guess he’s stopped applauding.

Kind regards

Daniel Kelly

 
1 Comment

Posted by on February 14, 2013 in Uncategorized

 

Clinical Record Entry – “Pre Race Check”

“Check” – Dictionary – Examine (something) in order to determine its accuracy, quality, or condition, or to detect the presence of something.

“Pre-race check” – Nicky Henderson, Tom Symonds, Ben Pauling and James Main – a protocol developed over several years between the practice and Mr Henderson to conceal the administration of tranexamic acid by injection to a horse on a race day.

So for any of you who have not been following my tweets in recent days; In June 2009 headline in Telegraph was as follows:

Nicky Henderson has been fined a record £40,000 and banned from making entries for three months after being found guilty of administering an anti-bleeding drug to the Queen’s horse Moonlit Path at Huntingdon in February.

BHA’s Full Decisions and Reasons can be found here; http://www.britishhorseracing.com/resources/about/whatwedo/disciplinary/disciplinaryDetail.asp?item=089819 but initially I want to focus on one section in particular:

Evidence at this Enquiry

12. The main factual evidence came just from Henderson. He had given notice that he intended to call Mr Main, and he also produced a statement signed on 3 June 2009 from him. This statement was also sent direct by Mr Main to the BHA on 3 June, under cover of a letter in which he expressed disagreement with the note compiled by the BHA investigators of his interview on 9 April. (Mr Main had refused to allow this to be recorded at the time). But on 18 June 2009, the BHA was informed by Henderson’s representatives that Mr Main would not be called to give evidence, because he was refusing to come.

13. As will be apparent from the analysis of this case below, it is obvious that Mr Main had some important, perhaps vital evidence to give. The Panel therefore raised with the parties the possibility of adjourning the enquiry to see if Mr Main might respond to invitations to attend from the BHA or even from the Panel direct. Mr Norris QC for Henderson forcefully opposed this course, and Mr McPherson QC for the BHA doubted whether Mr Main might respond to their invitation, because of the earlier dispute with him about the accuracy of the 9 April interview note.

14. The Panel saw an additional possible benefit from an adjournment. This would have allowed evidence to be taken from Tom Symonds, who was also, in the Panel’s view, someone with an important story to tell. But Mr Norris QC’s reaction to that was again to resist any adjournment, because he did not propose to call any evidence from Symonds. The Panel’s eventual decision was not to adjourn, because it was uncertain whether Mr Main would agree to give evidence, even with the “encouragement” he might be given by drawing his attention to Rule 6 of the Rules of Racing. It remained the Panel’s view that Mr Main and Mr Symonds had potentially crucial evidence to give.

So what was this evidence? Well we had to wait for the findings of the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeon to be published on the 22nd February 2011, http://www.rcvs.org.uk/document-library/main-feb-2011-findings.

Here are the best bits:

12) Henderson said in evidence that he “did not think that we had administered anything terribly illegal and the horse had not exactly won the race”.

21) Main said that it was widely used by other veterinary surgeons and trainers on race days to treat horses with a history of EIPH.

24) The Committee was unimpressed by Mr Henderson’s evidence and were surprised by his apparent lack of knowledge of the rules of racing. It considered that Mr Symonds and Mr Pauling did their best to assist the Committee in difficult circumstances.

25) Committee accepts Mr Main’s oral evidence that he, and other veterinary surgeons at the practice, had administered tranexamic acid to horses on race days at Mr Henderson’s yard over a significant period of time without positive testing.

25) While it is evident from the BHA’s Guidelines that the sensitivity of the tests is in a process of continual development, the Committee is unable to speculate as to why tranexamic acid had not tested positive on horses to which Mr Main had administered it on previous occasions.

32) Committee has concluded that the use of the term was, in effect, a protocol developed over several years between the practice and Mr Henderson to conceal the administration of tranexamic acid by injection to a horse on a race day.

32) It is sure that the underlying purpose shared by both Mr Main and Mr Henderson was to conceal a breach of Instruction C9 when the BHA inspected the yard’s records. Both Mr Symonds and Mr Pauling showed obvious discomfiture during their evidence when admitting that they knew that no substance should be given to a horse on a race day other than normal food and water and that was why injections of tranexamic acid were not entered into the yard’s own medication record.

So what happened next?

Well Tom Symonds left and started training himself – Be interested to hear the motives behind that move.

and…er…well that’s it.

So with the findings highlighting a protocol to conceal the administration of banned substances by calling the procedure a “pre race check”, Did the BHA review the clinical records of all Mr Henderson’s horses?

Did the BHA review their penalty following the evidence of Mr Main, Mr Symonds and Mr Pauling? A reminder of what was said by BHA QC at the Disciplinary Hearing; Mr McPherson QC for the BHA doubted whether Mr Main might respond to their invitation, because of the earlier dispute with him about the accuracy of the 9 April interview note.

Has Mr Main been approached by the BHA with regards to his statement of the protocol being used by other trainers on race day?

There are many more questions that need answering after you have read both documents. Be interested to know what questions you would like to ask the BHA or Mr Henderson. Please use the comments section below.

 
2 Comments

Posted by on February 13, 2013 in Uncategorized

 
 
Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free